The Cubs finished the weekend by taking two of three from the Brewers and eight of their last nine overall. They are now 40-40, and stand 6.5 games out of first. With the team exactly one game away from the half-way point, that's not a bad place to be. Don't get me wrong, I'd certainly rather be in the Brewers shoes right now, but the division is within reach and that's a helluva lot better than this time last year. So how did the Cubs go from a miserable 66 wins last year to comfortable mediocrity, within striking distance in a lousy division this year? Simple. They bullied their way in with cold, hard, cash. Throw $300 million dollars at a team and you better improve. Let's hand out some mid-term grades.
Marquis, Lilly, B+
The two big free agent pitchers have come in here and done their jobs. Throw some innings and give the team a chance to win. That's all you could ask for, and something the 2006 Cubs had a severe problem with.
Hill, Marshall, B+
The young lefties have each been shelled a few times, and when they're "off" they're horrible. But three quarters of their starts range from respectable to downright awesome. Nice job.
Zambrano, B-
If I were grading the last month, he'd get an A+. He's been superhuman these last four starts. If only he had pitched half this well in April and May, he'd be a shoo-in for the All-Star game. Instead, he's on the "final vote" ballot, waiting for the fans to put him in. With the rabid support of Cubs fans around the country, he's got a decent shot of making it. Not that he necessarily deserves it. One hot month does not an All-Star make.
Middle Relief, B-
These losers get a B-? Are you kidding? No, I'm not. Yeah, they're not great, but that's par for the course with middle relievers. Honestly, you want to see bad relief pitching? Head to the South Side. I'll gladly go with Marmol, Weurtz, Ohman, and Howry. Don't ask my opinion of Eyre, though. He's a DFA in tight pants.
Closer, B
Dempster's done his job this year, and Marmol/Howry haven't been too shabby while Ryan's been on the shelf.
Lee, B
Love the average, love the doubles, love the on-base-percentage. Miss the homers. A lot. I remember when Ryne Sandberg broke his wrist in the early 90s. He followed up back-to-back 26-homer seasons with a 9-homer season. He still hit .309, but didn't any power to speak of. The good news is he eventually did get back to the 25-homer range, and I suspect Lee will eventually get his power back, though not likely until next year. Still, even without the homers he's still a deserving All-Star.
DeRosa, A-
I was kind of down on this signing, but he's turned into a real asset. He not only plays a different position every day, he plays them well. And his bat has certainly been solid enough for a supersub. He doesn't make idiot plays either, what the Cubs have specialized in. (picked off, throwing to wrong base, etc.) Good signing.
Theriot, Fontenot, B+
These rookies have been real pleasant surprises this year. It seems odd for a Cubs prospect to come up and contribute. I'm used to guys coming up and hitting .220.
Izturis, C
He is who we thought he was. Solid on D, not much of a stick.
Ramirez, B
He's hustling, he's doing his job. He's hitting walk-offs. He's doing what we expect of him.
Soriano, A-
A deserving All-Star. So far, so good, on the signing; though there's still an awful lot of baseball to be played in the next 7.5 years. I think it's time to explore dropping Soriano in the lineup. Yes, his speed is great and he steals bases and he likes hitting leadoff. Got it. But he's got 15 homers, and 14 of them are solo shots. That's not right. I know he hits leadoff, and that means the he doesn't get the RBI opportunities of a cleanup hitter. Duh. But he has 96 ABs with runners on base, and in those at-bats he has exactly one jack. That trivia nugget aside, I'd still drop him down and take advantage of that power. How about something like this:
Theriot/Fontenot
Lee
Soriano
Ramirez
Floyd
DeRosa
Pie/Pagan
Bowen/Hill
At first glance, Lee hitting second seems ridiculous. But if he's not going to hit for power, you might as well get the most from that .419 OBP. Even if they drop down Alfonso, the bottom third is a black-hole. Michael Barrett's bat is missed. Speaking of...
Hill/Bowen/Blanco, C+
All three play good-to-great defense; all three hit like shit. After watching all those balls get by Barrett, though, I'm ok with trying the "defense" approach for a while.
Pie/Pagan, C
Really good defense from Pie, but horrible hitting. OK defense and OK hitting from Pagan. I expect more from Pie. The dude was hitting .385 in AAA, so we know he can hit. He's just got to stop getting sawed off in the bigs.
Floyd, B
When healthy, he's looked pretty good. He hasn't hit many homers, but when he gets ahold of one, he really gets ahold of one. He only has 4 homers this year, but I remember every last one of them as they were all moon shots.
Jones, Murton, D
I think he'd be OK if he played every day, but there's no doubt he sucks ass as a part-timer. Who am I talking about? Both of them.
The fact that I don't like Jones is well-documented. But he's been truly awful this year. I understand he's going through "tough times," being on the trading block and all. And it's certainly got to be hard going from "every day player" to "platoon." But screw that, he's making five million. Not a lot for a baseball player but nothing to sneeze at either. I expect more than .220, 2 homers, and wretched defense.
And Murton? I'd like to give him one more shot, but he's got to improve his D and actually out-hit Floyd before I just hand him the job. I don't think it's going to happen.
Ward, B
He's done a decent job in the pinch.
Piniella, B+
He may be rubbing some of the players the wrong way, but so far I'm a fan of Lou. He hasn't really had any bonehead lineups, and he generally gives the right players the most playing time. Plus, he kicks hats pretty darned well.
Hendry, B
Sure, the $300 million dollars worth of signings look good so far, but I'm still not exactly jumping up and down when I think of the number of years on Marquis' contract. I'm not going to knock him for that, though, as like I said, it's looked good so far.
I am going to knock him for the corner outfield spots, though. He got four Left Fielders and hoped it would sort itself out. If Soriano could have played Center, it would have. But when the Fonz moved to Left, they were forced to platoon three guys that were not only out-of -position, but also ineffective part-time players. It's a major reason the team was so lousy early on.
I think Lou has finally figured it out. Platoon Floyd and DeRosa in right. Ship out Jones (please!) It's a shame it took two months, though, to sort out what Hendry could have fixed back in November.
As for the rest of the season, I'm cautiously optimistic that they can make a run. The odds are against the team, but at least they're within reach. All in all, a decent step forward from last year. All I could ask.