In a word, no. The Bears lost to Pittsburgh today 21-9. Kyle Orton didn't help the team win, but he didn't lose the game either. The defense lost this game. And the coaching staff. But not Orton.
The Bears vaunted defense did not live up to the hype today at Heinz Field. Short both starting safeties, they simply could not stop Jerome Bettis when it mattered. They really missed Mike Brown. Lovie Smith threw Mike Green under the bus earlier this week when talking about his game play, and further shat on him when choosing Todd Johnson to start for injured Chris Harris. When Mike Brown pulled up lame on Friday, Lovie had no choice but to start Green, too. Green was so bad today, some guy named Brandon McGowan replaced him in the fourth (and did pretty well, I might add.) Green wasn't alone in his failures, though. The entire defense hardly came within sniffing distance of Ben Roethlisberger and missed tackles all day. It was pretty sad. That said, I'm not too concerned with this defense in the long run. (So long as Mike Brown is back next week as expected.) Every team has a day where things just don't go right. Even the magical '85 team had a well-publicized stinker against Miami. (If there is a bright side to this loss, it might end some of the comparisons to Buddy Ryan's '85 crew. We can resume that conversation once these Bears start shutting teams out in the playoffs.)
On offense, like I said, Orton wasn't terrible. No picks, no fumbles. Nothing really close to a pick, I might add. He did lead them on two nice scoring drives, though the first one stalled at the goal line forcing the team to settle for a field goal. Orton shook off a couple of sacks and overall looked rather mediocre. These Bears generally win with mediocrity at quarterback, and we really can't expect much more from a rookie. Orton deserves at least one more start. If he fails to inspire the offense next week, and the Bears lose again, give Grossman a look against Green Bay. If Orton doesn't blow next week's game and the Bears win, all Grossman talk should be shelved till the offseason. No sense switching your starting QB with only two weeks left in the season unless you absolutely have to.
Muhsin Muhammed had his finest game as a Bear. Eight catches, broken tackles, and big first downs. This is what Orton needs more of to succeed. Welcome back, Moose. Thomas Jones had two really nice runs but was otherwise quiet for the rest of the day.
Bobby Wade muffed another punt, and in other news the sun came up. Robbie Gould shanked an extra point in the snow, and really sucked the life out of the Bears brief rejuvination in the fourth quarter. In addition, special teams was responsible for the “What the hell are they thinking?” call of the day. In a blinding snowstorm, Gould lined up for a 52-yard field goal. The same Robbie Gould that probably couldn't hit a 52-yarder in practice, in a dome. My first thought, “this has GOT to be a fake.” And of course, it was. Gould pooched it and Pittsburgh was sitting there waiting. They caught the punt and returned it to the 25 (net gain of about 12 yards of field position). While the play wasn't exactly a tide turner, and had zero effect on the game's final outcome, it was still stupid. You're not fooling anyone with that move so why do it?
The coaching in general was kind of shaky. Ron Turner's offense didn't stretch the field at all, and they didn't play-action enough. There really weren't any Shoop-esque “Are you a F$%$ing idiot?” plays called, but there wasn't any “hey, that was a great idea!” plays either. Also, Chico's defense didn't seem to adjust for the Bus. He just ran, and ran, and ran, all day.
So the eight-game winning streak is over, and the Bears lead over the Brad Johnson-led Vikings is down to one with three games to play. Those pesky Vikings just won't go away so the Bears are going to have to earn their playoff spot the old fashioned way. The Bears still have a stronghold on the #2 seed, so it's not like it's time to panic. But watching any loss such as today, you start to wonder if they've got what it takes. They've got Atlanta at home next Sunday night on ESPN, and it's a perfect opportunity for the team to start another winning streak. Go Bears!!